Map

Shelter Island Homes for Sale

(7)
Sort:
<
1
20
>
$1,600,000
4 beds
3 full baths
2,532 sq. ft
10 Cove Way
Shelter Island NY 11964
Courtesy Of Laffey Fine Homes International
<
1
15
>
$1,149,000
2 beds
1 full bath
1,200 sq. ft
56 Brander Pky
Shelter Island NY 11964
Courtesy Of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
<
1
20
>
$982,800
6 beds
4 full baths
1 half bath
4,128 sq. ft
13 Locust Woods Dr
Shelter Island NY 11964
Courtesy Of Island Advantage Realty, LLC
<
1
1
>
$975,000
4 beds
3 full baths
1 half bath
10 Boro Hall Ln
Shelter Island NY 11964
Courtesy Of Town and Country Real Estate of the North Fork, LLC
<
1
16
>
$825,000
3 beds
1 full bath
1 half bath
1,496 sq. ft
49 Brander Pky
Shelter Island NY 11964
Courtesy Of Town and Country Real Estate of the North Fork, LLC
<
1
1
>
$780,000
65 Peconic Ave
Shelter Island NY 11964
Courtesy Of Town and Country Real Estate of the North Fork, LLC
Open House
<
1
14
>
$759,000
3 beds
2 full baths
1 half bath
1,894 sq. ft
2 Behringer Ln
Shelter Island NY 11964
Courtesy Of Realmart Realty
There are 7 real estate listings found in Shelter Island, NY. View our Shelter Island real estate area information to learn about the weather, local school districts, demographic data, and general information about Shelter Island, NY. Get in touch with a Shelter Island real estate agent who can help you find the home of your dreams in Shelter Island. Use our mortgage calculator to see how much it would be to finance a home in Shelter Island. Not ready to buy yet? Find and compare apartments for rent in Shelter Island.