CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc. Back to Search Results


  • 2016 - CENTURION
  • 2016 - President's Producer
  • 2016 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2015 - Masters Diamond
  • 2015 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2014 - CENTURION
  • 2014 - President's Producer
  • 2014 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2013 - CENTURION
  • 2013 - President's Producer
  • 2013 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2012 - Masters Emerald
  • 2012 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer

Professional Designations

  • Accredited Buyer Representative
  • Certified Short Sales and Foreclosures Resource
  • Commercial Specialist
  • REALTOR, National Association of REALTORS
  • Broker Price Opinion Resource

Colleen McMahon of CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.

CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
Colleen McMahon of CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
President's Producer
Learn More

Other Awards & Recognition

Century 21 CENTURION Award winner 2013 & 2014

New Jersey Association of Realtors Distinquished Sales Award

Accredited Buyers Representative ABR

New Jersey Association of Realtors Circle of Excellence Award 1999-2014, Silver 2012, GOLD 2013-2014

Century 21 Masters Award, Ruby 2003, 2011 Emerald 2004, 2012

Century 21 Crest Real Estate TOP ACHIEVER 2004-2008, 2013

Graduate 21 Plus Training Course

Certified Member of VIP Relocation Service

Certified Member of Mature Moves


Personal Profile

Century 21 Professional Agent for 21 years. I have served the housing needs of individuals in Pequannock & Pompton Plains as well as many of the surrounding areas. I am a lifelong resident of Pequannock Township which increases my knowledge of the community and has given me an understanding of all aspects of the real estate market... homes in all price ranges, schools, taxes and places of worship.


Certified Short Sales and Foreclosure Specialist

REALTOR, National Association of Realtors

Get Directions to the Office

Get Directions 142 Route 23 North Pompton Plains NJ 07444
Add to Favorites Remove Favorite Share
142 Route 23 North
Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
mobile: 973.214.5250

Overall Rating: 5.0
Locations Served:
Contact Agent
How should we contact you? *
* Required Fields
Overall Rating: 187 Ratings
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
January 2017
We highly, highly recommend Colleen McMahon as a realtor. She will sell your house in the shortest amount of time, at the highest price, and with the least amount of hassle to you. She has a wonderful personality, is so hard-working, and so caring. We loved getting to know Colleen during the marketing of our home. She is truly outstanding.
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
December 2016
Colleen A. McMahon made the house buying transition smooth and was available 24/7 for any questions or concerns I had. I would recommend her 100% . She was right on top of everything and made sure things were done in a timely manner.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
September 2016
She truly represents her customer.

Don't ever let Colleen go to another agency. She is the best agent we have ever worked with.

She kept in contact with all of us (Mom and Dad, And my two brothers) on a daily basis. From May until the closing in August. She communicated with us every day. Outstanding commitment to us. She couldn't have done anything more for us.

Colleen is not only interested in listing the property and then walking away. She stays with the property and actively markets it and then when a sale is made stays on every detail until the closing. She is the best. And she actually knew the details of the property and sale better than our attorney and did not hesitate to correct him on several occasions. Without her this would never have worked out to our satisfaction.

Colleen provided outstanding research documents to validate her marketing plan and price. She sold herself by her expertise and professionalism. She demonstrated her talent, professionalism, knowledge and work ethic which in our opinion is second to none.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
July 2016
Coleen is the only person to use when buying or selling! Her years of experience and proven record speaks for itself.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
July 2016
Colleen McMahon was exactly what we wanted in a realtor from the first time we met her until the closing of our home. She always communicated with us and explained the process in detail. She made the selling of our house easy and with the least amount of stress. Her knowledge and expertise got the job done. Colleen was very responsive, thorough, always was professional, and had knowledge of the local real estate. She was upfront and kept us informed on everything happening. We are so happy and appreciative of all her hard work and dedication to get our house sold as fast as she did. We would definitely recommend Colleen to anyone who needs a realtor. Colleen McMahon gives exceptional service.

We are looking forward now to working with her on purchasing our forever home and know she will offer us excellent service.

Thank you Colleen!!
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
July 2016
As a first time home buyer Colleen was the perfect agent for me. She is extremely knowledgeable, helpful and always fun to work with. My home buying process could not have gone any smoother and I would highly recommend Colleen to any buyer.
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
May 2016
Colleen is a reputable broker in Pequannock Township and she is extremely knowledgeable about the town. Colleen was constantly in contact with me throughout the entire process of purchasing a home and answering any questions or concerns I had. The closing was very well organized and went smoothly because Colleen was thoroughly prepared. .Colleen was a pleasure to work with throughout the process of buying my home! I would highly recommend her to anyone!
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
May 2016
Colleen McMahon gives her clients exceptional service and I would definitely recommend her. She made us completely at ease during the whole process. Colleens knowledge and expertise got the job done.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
May 2016
Colleen was the best person for our situation. She was always available to help me and I trusted her judgement and expertise. She was great! I would definitely recommend her to others.
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
April 2016
Colleen was knowledgeable, prompt and always available for me. She listened to what I was looking for and found me a perfect home.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
April 2016
Colleen was so very kind and helpful throughout the whole process of buying and selling my home. She was very attentive to all my needs,always calling or texting back ,right away,with all of my concerns and questions. She went out of her way many times to make sure my concerns or issues were met. Colleen spent time with me during the sale of my house as well as taking me to see new homes. She always made it convenient for me and I never felt rushed while looking at homes. She was able to give me professional opinions when I needed it. I am very happy with Colleen's professionalism and very glad to have made a new friend in the process. I thank her very much for all she did for me.

Selling my home was made much easier with the help and support of Colleen
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
February 2016
Colleen was great working with and understanding. Will work with her in the near future.
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
January 2016
From start to finish Colleen was there for us. We couldn't have asked for a better agent!! She went above & beyond for us!! Thank you thank you thank you!!! Use Colleen!! She'll help you find your perfect home!!
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
November 2015
Colleen was very helpful in marketing our home. She gave very helpful info and made our sale go well. Home was sold in ten days buy a different realtor. Would recommend Colleen to others preparing to sell
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
November 2015
Colleen A. McMahon was very helpful in taking care of appointments/errands for us, since she was local to the house we had on the market, and saved us numerous trips/miles/time by doing so.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
October 2015
Easy and stress free sale from start to finish. Colleen handled everything with ease that is why we chose her to sell our home!
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
August 2015
Simply put.. Colleen McMahon is pro and we believe she would be a wonderful mentor to the less experienced Realtors! Thanks Colleen for your sincere knowledge .. attention to detail .. honesty .. and your enthusiasm that never failed .. We truly appreciate all of your hard work!


Lisa & Bill DAmico
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
July 2015
As a first time home buyer, Colleen McMahon treated me with all the patience and guidance that I required. She was exactly the person that I needed!
Colleen McMahon | Buyer Rating
June 2015
We were extremely happy with Colleen's patience and understanding while trying to find out family home. We were relocating from an hour away and had a timeline of a new baby on the way. Colleen worked with us and did not push us into any house knowing that we had some time to wait for the perfect house for our growing family.

She was extremely knowledgable in all the areas that we were looking for our home which helped our search greatly. When we finally found our home, Colleen helped us through the closing process with great attention to detail and eased all our concerns. Even though we don't plan on moving any time soon, we would definitely use Colleen again and would highly recommend her to anyone looking in the area.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
June 2015
Colleen was very thorough and always on top of everything. She was easy to get in touch with and always responded to our questions and concerns quickly. She was very proactive in helping to get out house sold with all of the advertising and with the open houses.
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
May 2015
I knew from others in town that Colleen McMahon was top notch. The fact that she knows Pequannock Twp. so well is a real plus, in my opinion. When I initially reached out to her, Colleen got right back to me and we set an appointment right away. Throughout the process, Colleen was always available to answer questions and do her best to get our house sold! I would definitely recommend Colleen McMahon!
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
May 2015
Colleen thank you for all your help in making this transition as easy as possible!
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
April 2015
Colleen A. McMahon is a knowledgeable, dedicated Realtor, who provided us with a quick, problem free sale. She was always available to answer our questions, and a pleasure to work with.

Colleen designed a detailed and honest listing of our property which beautifully showcased our home. Many buyers indicated interest, and we had our contract 12 days after the listing posted!

Throughout the contract process, Colleen kept us up to date on every aspect of the sale. She was our truly our lifeline, and made the entire process easy and understandable.

We would highly recommend Colleen for any real estate transaction. She is a true professional, and made our entire experience a pleasure!
Colleen McMahon | Seller Rating
March 2015
We appreciate Colleen A. McMahon's help in selling our house - we received an offer within the first week on the market. As we were not residing near our house, Colleen was there to keep an eye on it and represent us during inspections. She is a powerhouse and will get the job done!
* Some customers who provided a testimonial may have received a Starbucks gift card from their CENTURY 21 Sales Professional as a thank you for completing the customer satisfaction survey.
Colleen McMahon's Listings See All of Colleen McMahon's Listings


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
4 bedrooms
2 full baths
1 half bath
MLS# 3365101
Unhide Property: 34 Sherman Ave., Pompton Plains, NJ 07444 | $679,900


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
MLS# 3351174
Unhide Property: 96 Hopper Ave., Pompton Plains, NJ 07444 | $599,900


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
2,039 SQ FT
MLS# 3360146
Unhide Property: 40 Prospect Ave., Pompton Plains, NJ 07444 | $499,900


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
MLS# 3362139
Unhide Property: 15 E Belleview Ave., Butler, NJ 07405 | $359,900


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
2 bedrooms
2 full baths
1 half bath
1,918 SQ FT
MLS# 3366634
Unhide Property: B2 Suburbian Village, Wanaque, NJ 07465 | $349,900


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
MLS# 3363367
Unhide Property: 242 Terrace Lake Dr., Butler, NJ 07405 | $319,900


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
Sun, Mar 5th - 1:00PM to 4:00PM
2 bedrooms
2 full baths
1 half bath
1,628 SQ FT
MLS# 3363516
Unhide Property: 58 Toms Point Ln., Lincoln Park, NJ 07035 | $315,000


Listed By CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.
MLS# 1644775
Unhide Property: 121 Myer St.#402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 | $259,900
CENTURY 21 real estate agent Colleen McMahon currently has 8 listings. Colleen McMahon speaks . Colleen McMahon works at the CENTURY 21 real estate office Crest Real Estate, Inc. located in 142 Route 23 North, Pompton Plains, New Jersey. Contact Colleen McMahon by phone by calling 973.214.5250.