Skip to main content
Back to Search Results
|

546 Castle Street, Geneva, NY 14456

Show All 50 Photos
For Sale

$825,000

7 beds • 3 baths • 1 half baths

Estimated Payment

$      /mo. †

APR for 30 years

Change Loan Terms

  • Single Family Detached
    Property type

  • Newly Listed
    Time on Century 21

  • 1862
    Year built

  • Over 50 Years Old
    Age

Explore this Property

Offered to the open market for the first time in over 160 years, this circa 1862 brick colonial is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Geneva's rich history. Built by Thomas Smith, co-founder of the W & T Smith Nursery Company, this stately residence was the first grand home on Castle Street and has remained in the Smith family for generations. Spanning 4,700+ sq. ft. and set on nearly 2 acres, this home offers 5-7 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and an original two-story carriage house. Perfect as a single-family residence or an exceptional Bed & Breakfast, the property combines timeless character with extensive modern updates. The home has recently undergone a comprehensive renovation, including a brand-new roof, complete re-wiring, all new plumbing, renovated bathrooms, and a brand-new kitchen designed for today's lifestyle. Original wood flooring has been beautifully refinished, and the entire home has been freshly painted, providing a move-in-ready experience while preserving historic charm. Steeped in history, this residence reflects the legacy of the Smith family, who immigrated from England in the 1830s and built one of Geneva's most influential businesses. The nursery they founded flourished across Castle Street, and the family's grand homes became neighborhood landmarks. Thomas Smith's residence, completed in 1862, was the first of these remarkable properties, later joined by others built by his brother William Smith, founder of William Smith College, and Thomas's son. The elegant architecture, generous room sizes, and carriage house create endless possibilities for the next owner. Whether you envision a private family retreat, a boutique inn, or a blend of historic living and modern convenience, 546 Castle Street offers unmatched potential and a chance to continue a legacy over a century in the making.
MLS# R1635885

Listed By CENTURY 21 Steve Davoli Real Estate

Open Houses

September

13

Saturday

In Person

Saturday, September 13, 2025

11:00AM - 1:00PM

Property Features

  • Age
    Over 50 Years Old
  • Area Description
    Historic / Antique
  • Basement
    Full
  • Exterior
    Carriage House
  • Exterior Description
    Brick
  • Exterior Living Space
    Porch
  • Fireplace Count
    3 Fireplaces
  • Fireplace Description
    Brick, Wood Burning
  • Flooring
    Hardwood, Tile
  • Garage Count
    2 Car Garage
  • Garage Description
    Detached Garage
  • Heating Type
    Steam Heat
  • Interior
    Cathedral Ceilings
  • Kitchen Features
    Center Island
  • Lot Description
    Irregular
  • Lot Size
    2-5 Acres, 2 Acres
  • Road Type
    City / Town Street
  • Roof
    Rubber
  • Sewer
    Public
  • Special Market
    Vacation / Second Home, College / University, Luxury Properties
  • Style
    2 Story
  • Water
    Municipal Water

Map and Directions

Directions to 546 Castle Street, Geneva, NY 14456

Home seller Meet the Agent,
Daniel Toner

Get to know the neighborhood. A local affiliated CENTURY 21 agent will help you set up tours, give advice, and negotiate with sellers.

Daniel Toner

of CENTURY 21 Steve Davoli Real Estate

License: 10401281611
(315) 719-4045
Learn More About Me

Mortgage Calculator

$
$ %
Loan Term
%
Invalid number

$ /year
$ /year
$ /month

Monthly Payment Breakdown

  • Principle and Interest
    $0
  • Property Taxes
    $0
  • Hazard Insurance
    $0
  • Private Mortgage Insurance
    $0
  • HOA Dues
    $0
  • Total Monthly Payment:
    $0

Calculators provided for estimating purposes only. Consult with your lender to determine precise payment requirements.

An Equal Opportunity Company

Data powered by Attom Data Solutions. Copyright© 2025. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

This information is provided for general informational purposes only and should not be relied on in making any home-buying decisions. School information does not guarantee enrollment. Contact a local real estate professional or the school district(s) for current information on schools. This information is not intended for use in determining a person's eligibility to attend a school or to use or benefit from other city, town or local services.

† Based on a 30-year fixed rate of 3.38% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Interest rates are also subject to credit and property approval based on secondary market guidelines. The rates shown are based on average rates for our best qualified customers. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.

Loading