
Awards
- 2024 - Quality Service Producer
Professional Designations
- REALTOR, National Association of REALTORS
Personal Profile
Raised in Carmel, Indiana, where I now live with my family, I bring unmatched local expertise and a deep commitment to serving my clients through every stage of their real estate journey. I offer exceptional real estate expertise and a full suite of services tailored to relocation, multigenerational moves, downsizing, right-sizing, move-up purchases, and first-time homebuying. My dedication to personalized service has earned me multiple Quality Service Awards and the prestigious Centurion Team Award at Century 21 for top-level production. Clients often describe me as knowledgeable, patient, and incredibly responsive?someone who listens and makes the process smooth, informed, and even enjoyable. I am committed to you and your next move, whether you're buying, selling, investing, or building?and look forward to helping you take the next step with confidence.
Locations Served (8)
Client Reviews
5 out of 5
-
Buyer reviewWe cannot recommend Amy Costidakis highly enough! Working with her was not only a pleasure, but a complete game-changer in what could have been a very stressful and overwhelming real estate experience. From the very beginning, Amy demonstrated a level of professionalism, care, and dedication that went far above and beyond what is typically expected of a real estate agent. She didn't just help us buy a home-she advocated for our family every step of the way, like we were her top priority. One of the best qualities about Amy is her constant and clear communication. She kept us updated on every detail and made herself available at all hours to answer questions and walk us through next steps. We never felt out of the loop. Her responsiveness was truly unmatched, and it gave us a tremendous sense of confidence in the process. She also has a deep market knowledge and even deeper network of professional contacts we are able to contract moving forward. We were truly impressed!
-
Seller reviewOur agent was Amy Costidakis and she was very knowledgeable of the current market trends in Carmel and Hamilton County. Amy was very helpful and straight forward with us on the sale of our home. Amy is a professional in every aspect of the real estate business. Amy responded quickly to all of our needs and questions. We would definitely hire Amy in the future as our agent in any real estate transaction. Amy displays so many top agent traits during every part of the real estate transaction including Honesty, Integrity, Local Market Knowledge, Realtor Professionalism, Markeing Knowledge (amazing) and Attention to Detail! Thank you Amy!
-
Buyer reviewAmy was provided to us by our relocation team, and did we luck out! She was extremely knowledgeable about each suburb, neighborhood, and builder. She showed us properties via FaceTime since we were relocating from out of state. She met every inspector, contractor, and family member at the house on our behalf. She made the whole process easy and went above and beyond our expectations!
-
Seller reviewAmy was absolutely wonderful to work with. She made us feel like family. She was open,honest, professional and very trustworthy! We would absolutely recommend her 100%!! Definitely will be using her again!! I can't say enough positive things about her!!
-
Seller reviewAmy Costidakis is wonderful to work with and we appreciated all her time and energy working on our house sale. She was very easy to work with and always pleasant to talk to. She also does a good job keeping you calm during the normal negotiations that happen after inspection and up until closing. It's stressful selling a house, no matter how well it goes, and Amy has a wonderful way of keeping things calm and friendly. We really appreciated Amy and felt that her advice was helpful. She sold our house quickly so we could focus on all the normal craziness of life and moving.
-
Seller reviewAmy is one of the most amazing realtors and is an all around wonderful human being! She cares deeply about each of her clients and bends over backward to ensure not just a successful sale, but that the experience is tailored to meet your needs. I would buy and/or sell over and over again with Amy Costidakis! She's one in a billion!

Get in touch with Amy Costidakis
(5) 32 RatingsCENTURY 21 Scheetz
270 East Carmel Drive
Carmel, IN 46032
Mobile:
(317) 430-7819
Phone:
(317) 844-5111
Office:
(317) 844-5111
Fax:
(317) 843-4450
Toll-free:
(888) 724-3389