Skip to main content
Headshot of Colleen McMahon

Colleen McMahon of CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.

(5) 393 Ratings
Luxury specialist
Commercial specialist
|
Get in Touch

Awards

  • 2024 - Masters Emerald
  • 2024 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2023 - Masters Diamond
  • 2023 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2022 - CENTURION®
  • 2022 - President's Producer
  • 2022 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2021 - CENTURION®
  • 2021 - President's Producer
  • 2021 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2020 - CENTURION®
  • 2020 - President's Producer
  • 2020 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer

Professional Designations

  • Accredited Buyer Representative
  • Short Sales and Foreclosure Resource
  • Certified Relocation Professional
  • Commercial Specialist
  • Fine Homes and Estates Specialist
  • REALTOR ASSOCIATE, National Assoc of REALTORS
  • REALTOR, National Association of REALTORS
  • Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
  • Broker Price Opinion Resource

Personal Profile

CENTURY 21® Professional Full Time REALTOR® since 1994 & TOP PRODUCER. I have served the housing needs of individuals in Pequannock & Pompton Plains as well as many of the surrounding areas. I am a lifelong resident of Pequannock Township which increases my knowledge of the community and has given me an understanding of all aspects of the real estate market... homes in all price ranges, schools, taxes, and places of worship.

"Pequannock Township Citizen of the Year 2025"

Serving Morris, Passaic, Sussex, Bergen, Warren, and Monmouth Counties.

New Jersey Realtors® CIRCLE OF EXCELLENCE Gold Award 2023, Silver Award 2024

CENTURY 21® CENTURION 2022

CENTURY 21® PRESIDENT'S AWARD 2022

CENTURY 21® PINNACLE QUALITY SERVICE AWARD 2024

ABR®. SFR. BPO

Member of North Central Jersey Board of Realtors

Member of Garden State Multiple Listing Service

Member of New Jersey Multiple Listing Service


Client Reviews

5 out of 5

(5) 393 Ratings
  • Buyer review
    I always knew that when it was time for me to start the process of buying a house, I would go with Colleen! Having known her for most of my life, I knew that she was someone I could trust with such an important process. Beyond my personal experience with her, her reputation is unmatched. I knew that she would be incredibly knowledgeable about any of the towns we looked in, in addition to the ins and outs of the houses we saw. Working with someone I could trust and whose input I value was of the utmost importance to me. Colleen was amazing in all of the above aspects. She is SO knowledgeable about everything - the houses themselves and the communities they're in. She was able to find us the perfect neighborhood that I had no idea existed! She made the whole overwhelming process incredibly smooth and easy. Colleen went above and beyond all of my expectations of an agent. She was constantly available for questions and concerns. She was patient with us and extremely informative throughout the whole process. She made us feel comfortable each step of the way. Casey McMahon/Podence was also INCREDIBLY helpful and fantastic throughout our search. She worked so hard alongside Colleen to help find us properties that fit our wants and needs. Casey was also incredibly knowledgeable about the properties we saw and the communities we visited. She also made us feel comfortable throughout our search. Colleen and Casey helped to make our experience as easy and smooth as possible. I'd recommend them to anyone (but especially other first time home buyers!) in a heartbeat. Truly a dynamic duo :)
  • Seller review
    Colleen is so knowledgeable in every aspect of real estate and was there every step of the way for me.
  • Buyer review
    Colleen's in-depth agent knowledge, mixed with her outstanding personality, made our first home purchase a great experience. Even in this crazy market, she maintained her composure and had us all laughing at every turn! We truly appreciate all she did!
  • Buyer review
    Colleen went above and beyond each day for looking for houses for our family. Once we found a house she got us the best price, she is like a working machine. Took in account that we needed a house right away. We ask for help with inspectors, lawyer, loan agent, she got us everyone we needed right away and all were a fit for us. I would highly recommend Colleen to anyone I know looking for a realtor. We never hesitated to contact Colleen if we had a question. She was always ahead of us before we needed to ask the question with the answer. I wouldn't use any other agent, Colleen is my go to person.
  • Seller review
    From the moment we decided to sell, we knew we had to use Colleen. She is very knowledgable and knows the business like no one else. It's clear to see why she wins for top sales time and time again. Colleen guided us through getting our house ready to sell, the selling process and the contract process. She was always just a call or text away, able to answer any of our questions. She truly made the selling process easy!
  • Seller review
    We would highly recommend Colleen A. McMahon to family and friends. She was extremely knowledgeable and professional. You can see that she loves what she does it shows in her performance. She was very knowledgeable in the closing end of the deal as well. Any questions regarding closing she knew it all. Highly recommended. FANTASTIC......WE LOVE OUR HOME. Thanks again Pauline and Richard Midthasssel
Showing 55 - 60 of 144

Get in touch with Colleen McMahon

(5) 393 Ratings

CENTURY 21 Crest Real Estate, Inc.

Contact Me By (required)