Skip to main content
Headshot of Michelle Nichols

Michelle Nichols of CENTURY 21 Scheetz

(5) 69 Ratings
Get in Touch


  • 2022 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2021 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2020 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2019 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2018 - Quality Service Producer

Professional Designations

  • REALTOR, National Association of REALTORS

Personal Profile

I am a graduate from Ball State University with a Bachelors Degree in Interior Design. I have 15 years of experience working for home builders in the Indianapolis area. While working in the home building industry I both managed the design center and sold new construction homes. I joined Century 21 Scheetz as an associate broker in October 2014. I am excited to use my past experiences along with the many tools made available to me by Century 21 Scheetz to provide superior service to you when you buy or sell your next home.

Client Reviews

5 out of 5

(5) 69 Ratings
  • Seller review
    We originally went with other broker who offered a lower rate of commission and indicated a high sell of our home. We struggled with little to no feed back or help to get our home sold. After our house sat on the market with no showings. I started to rethink Michelle's original advice. We had interviewed Michelle when we first started because a close friend recommended her and we passed due to commission. I decided to text her to see if what I was experiencing with the broker was normal. I wasn't really getting feedback or advice from the one I had chosen. Michelle was very kind in her response. She never spoke poorly of my broker and did provide some feedback of how one might try to sell my home. She even commented on a few of my home pictures and confirmed a few things I had thought. My home sale was going nowhere, my listing pictures were taken with an iPhone and the holidays were coming. My husband and I were beyond stressed. We asked our realtor for advice and she gave us real insight or plan of action. She indicated it would just take time. We requested she lower the price, since she had not suggested it. We deiced to ask Michelle for advice on how she might sell the home. She asked us about when our new home would be ready and seemed to really care about our home life balance…what our goals were. We wanted to stop stressing, sell our home by the time our new home was built and enjoy our holidays. She advised us to take the home off the market, wait until after the holidays, so we could enjoy them in peace. She listed the marketing she could do and just walked us through the whole process. We went with Michelle's advice and parted ways with our previous relator. What a DIFFERENCE. I cannot overstate how different the care was with Michelle. She seemed to anticipate my questions before I even asked them. She would keep us advised on home sales, the marketing and the open house. We felt heard and cared for. In my previous experience I was googleing everything to try and figure things out, with Michelle there was no need. She walked us through everything and had sooo much knowledge to share. My pictures were amazing!! We sold our home after 2 days and at a price we had hoped for. We had a few items that came up during the home inspection and she not only explained each item, gave us options on how to move forward, but also found us repair men. It was way above anything we had expected. We were more than happy to pay the commission for this level of service. She was the best! She turned our experience around and brought peace to the home selling process. She was such a blessing to our family. Thank you! Beyond what we expected. We were sooo happy with our sale and feedback from Michelle!
  • Buyer review
    I have been working with Michelle for over 2 years and we were finally able to find the perfect property. She was incredibly patient with me and very understanding of my needs. I will highly recommend her to anyone needing an agent!
  • Buyer review
    Michelle Nichols was great throughout the buying process. She was always available when I had questions and very knowledgeable!
  • Seller review
    Michelle's in-depth knowledge of the real estate market coupled with her background in interior design ensures that your home will be presented in the best possible way to potential buyers. She is very responsive and goes above and beyond for her clients. I highly recommend Michelle to anyone who is in the market for a new home.
  • Buyer review
    Michelle has helped my parents find a home in the past. She has always been very friendly, knowledgeable and professional. Michelle has built rapport with my family, and she exceeded my expectations when it was my turn to find a home. She was very flexible with her time. She paid a lot of attention to detail, and she kept my three year old son in mind when we viewed homes together. She was understanding of my budget and helped me find a lender who was very personable and thorough. She sent me reminders throughout the process so I could complete all of the steps in a timely manner. She made this process much easier than I expected because she was someone I could trust to get me through the home buying process. I recommend Michelle to others especially if they live in Johnson County because she knows the area well.
  • Buyer review
    Michelle Nichols came highly recommended from close friends and we wanted someone who came with great personal references. Michelle went above and beyond for us. We are first time home buyers and were faced with rather uncooperative and difficult situations during our home journey. Michelle Nichols was an incredible advocate for us during a stressful time and even went out of her way to take care of things that were outside of her responsibilities. And Michelle did it all with a positive attitude. Thank you, Michelle! I will be fully recommending Michelle Nichols to everyone looking to buy or sell their house!

Get in touch with Michelle Nichols

(5) 69 Ratings

CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Contact Me By (required)