Kristin Miller, McCordsville, IN
Caitlin was more than we could have hoped for in a realtor! Her ability to coach us and negotiate on both the sale of our home, and the purchase of a new home was impressive! Can't recommend her enough.
Caitlin McClain
Hi friend! Buying or selling a home is a big deal, and I don't take your trust lightly. Before becoming a Realtor, I bought, renovated, and sold multiple homes of my own, so I understand both the emotional and financial side of the process firsthand. My goal is simple: to add real, tangible value at every step, from strategic prep and staging/design guidance to thoughtful marketing, negotiation, and closing. With a 15-year background in design, I'm especially passionate about helping homes show at their absolute best, because thoughtful presentation directly impacts your bottom line. When I'm not working with clients, my husband and I are usually knee-deep in a DIY project, cheering on the Pacers at Gainbridge, or throwing a ball for my fluffy elder golden boy, Norman. You may also spot me vintage treasure hunting around Indy or riding my bike near Geist Reservoir. Say howdy, and feel free to reach out anytime....
Linda Kay, McCordsville
I've bought and sold many properties before and have never had a realtor as brilliant, communicative, knowledgeable, and all things good as Caitlin. She valued my home so much more than I thought I could get and with her staging, marketing, and people skills we had multiple offers the first weekend. If there was an issue, she had it solved before I even know about it. I have recommended her to everyone I know and almost wish I had another house to sell so I could work with her again. Selling a house has never been this fun....
Thomas Eugene, Indianapolis, IN
I highly recommend Caitlin McClain as your choice for a realtor to sell your home. She gave me great ideas on how to update and stage my house and included advice on what to avoid doing. I followed her suggestions and my home looked amazing!
Caitlin is a consummate professional and did an in-depth market analysis to establish an appropriate selling price. Caitlin marketed my house well and showed it several times. As a result, I was able to get a great offer on my home in less than a week!
Caitlin was always available and responsive to any questions or concerns that I had. She was a delight to work with throughout the selling process and kept me informed at all times. I have sold five homes previously and she is the best real estate agent I have ever had. If you are looking for someone to sell your home, Caitlin McClain should be your first choice....
Katterine Alvarenga, Plainfield, IN
Working with Caitlin was one of the most comforting and empowering experiences I’ve had in a long time. From the very first moment, she made me feel seen, heard, and supported. It wasn’t just about closing on a condo—it was about building a future for my family, and she understood that deeply.
She moved mountains to make things happen quickly and smoothly, always showing up with kindness, clarity, and unwavering dedication. Every question I had was met with patience and care. Every step felt like I had someone truly in my corner—not just professionally, but personally.
Her warmth, responsiveness, and genuine heart made all the difference. I never felt alone in the process. I felt guided, protected, and celebrated. If you’re looking for someone who brings not just expertise but soul to her work, Caitlin is the person you want by your side....
Caitlin's office
Contact Caitlin
Protect your home and budget from life's surprises with an Assurant Home Warranty, backed by a partner that supports you through every step of homeownership. Explore Plans.
©2026 Century 21 Real Estate LLC. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, the CENTURY 21 Logo and C21® are service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Century 21 Real Estate LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate.