Nicole understands that real estate is about far more than completing a transaction—it's about guiding people through one of the most important decisions of their lives. With 25 years of real estate sales experience, she has built her career on being not just a trusted advisor, but a skilled negotiator who brings clarity, confidence, and calm to every step of the home-buying or selling journey. Home purchases and sales can feel overwhelming, emotional, and even intimidating. Nicole's professional yet personal approach is designed to lift that weight from your shoulders. She is committed to making you feel protected, informed, and supported from the first conversation to the closing table and beyond, ensuring you always have a trusted resource long after the move is complete. Nicole has spent decades helping clients across the Indianapolis area—including, but not limited to, Noblesville, Fishers, Westfield, Carmel, Zionsville, Brownsburg, Indianapolis, Franklin, Whiteland, and Whitestown—find the right home and the right community to fit their needs. Over the years, she has guided 700+ families and individuals through successful moves, new beginnings, and major life transitions. As a highly skilled negotiator, Nicole advocates for her clients throughout the entire transaction—including inspections, appraisals, contract terms, and any other critical component that can influence the outcome. Her experience allows her to anticipate challenges, protect your interests, and secure the strongest possible position on your behalf. Nicole's expertise spans a wide range of clients, providing discretion, clarity, and strategic insight to everyone—from first-time home buyers to seasoned and luxury-market clients—ensuring each person receives a tailored and exceptional experience. She leverages the latest technology and marketing strategies to ensure your home receives maximum exposure to qualified buyers. Whether you need help with pre-qualification, selecting the right mortgage partner, choosing the best neighborhood, identifying the ideal home layout, or navigating new-construction options, Nicole's extensive experience allows her to walk you through the process with confidence and ease. With Nicole, you gain more than a real estate agent—you gain an advocate who is dedicated to your success, your comfort, and your peace of mind.
Nicole was excellent helping us understand the process of building a new house. This was our first time building, and she went above and beyond to ensure we knew what to expect and how to make the right decisions. She even went so far as to attend the design appointment with me while my wife was at home (out of state) with our newborn. Nicole also helped us escalate issues with the builder, and always had our back. She always made us feel valued and cared for. Throught the building process, Nicole was extremely professional, responsive, and caring. We highly recommend Nicole for your real estate needs!
3 years ago
Buyer Review
Suzie, Richmond Indiana
Love Nicole! Would recommend highly!
5 months ago
Seller Review
Hayley McInrue, Phoenix AZ
When it came to selling our home in Fishers, we knew we wanted to use Nicole again. She has expert knowledge of the Fishers area and more importantly the neighborhood we were selling in. After our family had relocated and the home was still on the market, Nicole went above and beyond by stopping into the home frequently to make sure everything was fine and there were no issues.
During the inspection period Nicole dealt with all the workers and was very clear in her communication back to us. Trying to sell a home and stay on top of everything when you are 3,000 miles away is daunting but Nicole managed the listing and sale with professionalism and we would recommend her to anyone wanting a smooth home selling process.
6 years ago
Seller Review
Greg & Katie Watts, Fishers
Nicole made a great first impression when she came to our home for our initial meeting - she was very warm and friendly and helped us feel comfortable with the process of selling our home.
Throughout the listing period, Nicole did a great job of keeping us informed with the status of what was going on and was always was very responsive when we had any questions.
We really enjoyed working with Nicole Peters and would definitely recommend her to others!
