Skip to main content
Headshot of Mary Caserta

Mary Caserta of CENTURY 21 Miller Elite

(5) 120 Ratings
License: SL532106
Get in Touch


  • 2023 - Quality Service Pinnacle Producer
  • 2022 - Quality Service Producer
  • 2021 - Masters Ruby
  • 2020 - Masters Emerald
  • 2019 - CENTURION®
  • 2019 - Quality Service Producer

Personal Profile

I have been been a licensed Florida real estate agent since December 1988, and have lived on Amelia Island since 1984. With my knowledge of the local real estate market and my professional real estate skills, I look forward to meeting and assisting all of my real estate customers.

Client Reviews

5 out of 5

(5) 120 Ratings
  • Buyer review
    Mary is an exceptional real estate agent. Coming from out of the State, we needed a lot of hand-holding to navigate the market. She made a potentially stressful experience relexing and even fun. She was not only there for us with every detail of the purchasing process, but also went above and beyond to help us settle down into our new home. We leaned on her for almost everything. She is prefessional, knowlegeable, patient and kind. She is such a credit to your company.
  • Seller review
    We attempted to sell this property by using a different broker/realtor. That broker/realtor has the property for about 9 months with no success. When we listed this property with Ms. Caserta, it was sold within 3 months. We greatly appreciate Ms. Caserta and would highly recommend her.
  • Seller review
    Ms. Caserta was extremely easy to work with. She listened, offered professional advice and was available for consultation as needed. Ms. Caserta was sensitive to the needs of our family and the complex nature of this sale. We would highly recommend Ms. Caserta and will definitely use her in the future.
  • Buyer review
    As a client in my 20's, navigating my first home purchase was initially an overwhelming experience until I was referred to Mary Caserta by a family member that had the pleasure of working with her for their purchase. Mary sent me listings that fit my wants and needs within the hour. She not only negotiated on my behalf keeping me 20k under my budget, but she found me the land of my dreams in Yulee, FL I thought I would never be able to get my hands on. Her professionalism and availability made it 110% easier to get through all the hectic commotion of the inspections, and her transparency helped me to make the most of my closing. I even had the pleasure of working with her co-representative James Caserta, who was kind enough to accompany me for inspections and helped me put together a nail biting closing after my sellers were hospitalized on our closing day by getting us a mobile notary. Thank you for helping me get my 2 year old his dinosaur room. I am so so thankful for you both.
  • Seller review
    Overall in all aspects she was one of the best I have dealt with lately and did an amazing job with everything.
  • Buyer review
    Mary is the best! My wife and I think of Mary not just as our realtor but as a close friend. I would recommend Mary to my friends and family.

Get in touch with Mary Caserta

(5) 120 Ratings

CENTURY 21 Miller Elite

Contact Me By (required)