Rachael
I would 100% use her again. Very personable. I felt like I was working with a friend
Tibitha Matheney
Spoken languages: English
Awards
2025
CENTURION©
2025
CENTURION© Honor Society
2024
CENTURION©
2023
CENTURION©
2023
Quality Service Producer
2022
CENTURION©
Angela Cottrill, Levittsburg, OH
Tibitha was incredible! We were first time home buyers and had no idea what to do. She walked is through every step and explained things as many times as needed. She truly cares about getting us the house we wanted.
Chuck Tarnovich
There is a reason Tibi is one of the top selling agents!!! She is on the ball and very knowledgeable about the market!!!
George G.
We recently just closed on our new home. I'm from the East Coast and was accustomed to the house buying experiences there. I was certain that we would be life long renters but Tibitha was able to help me finally see that home ownership was definitely in our future. She was able to help us narrow down exactly what we were looking for in our future home, showed us prospective houses quickly in this crazy market, shared her 20 years experience with us, and was able to answer all our crazy questions. We will absolutely use her in any future real estate needs and refer her to all friends and family for their home buying and selling needs.
Tibitha's listings
- New
$109,000Active1 beds 1 baths937 sq. ft.5200 West Boulevard #505, Youngstown, OH 44512
MLS# 5187384Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY 
$245,000Active3 beds 2 baths912 sq. ft.325 S Inglewood Avenue, Austintown, OH 44515
MLS# 5183654Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$319,900Active3 beds 3 baths2,020 sq. ft.583 Wyndclift Circle, Austintown, OH 44515
MLS# 5181221Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$69,900Active2 beds 2 baths1,056 sq. ft.104 S Glenellen Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44509
MLS# 5175605Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$99,900Active3 beds 1 baths1,596 sq. ft.212 S Schenley Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44509
MLS# 5175612Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$59,900Active3 beds 2 baths1,439 sq. ft.40 S Glenellen, Youngstown, OH 44509
MLS# 5171562Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$260,000Active3 beds 3 baths2,335 sq. ft.85 Lake Shore Drive, Boardman, OH 44511
MLS# 5175902Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$400,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,416 sq. ft.115 Hillside Drive, East Palestine, OH 44413
MLS# 5170362Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$400,000Active2 beds 2 baths1,435 sq. ft.135 Hillside Drive, East Palestine, OH 44413
MLS# 5170377Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$99,900Active6.83 Acres902 S Meridian Road, Austintown, OH 44509
MLS# 5155812Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$90,000Active3 beds 1 baths884 sq. ft.2101 Cherry Hill Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44509
MLS# 5148116Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
$37,000Active2.54 Acres909 Lisbon Road, Salem, OH 44460
MLS# 5111556Listed by: CENTURY 21 LAKESIDE REALTY
Tibitha's office
Contact Tibitha
Protect your home and budget from life's surprises with an Assurant Home Warranty, backed by a partner that supports you through every step of homeownership. Explore Plans.
©2026 Century 21 Real Estate LLC. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, the CENTURY 21 Logo and C21® are service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Century 21 Real Estate LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate.