My name is Sarah May, and I'm proud to call Neenah my home. With a passion for real estate and a commitment to providing top-notch service, I'm here to help you navigate the world of home buying and selling.
I'm a proud graduate of the University of Wisconsin-Madison, GO BADGERS! Over the years, I've amassed valuable experience in public relations, customer service, and account management, which have equipped me with the skills needed to excel in the real estate industry.
Family is at the core of my life. I have two wonderful boys, Isaac and Lucas and a boxer dog named Zelda. They keep me on my toes, challenge me, and make me laugh every day. My husband, Jesse, and I have a unique story - we met back in 9th grade in Fond du Lac (back when Goodrich was the high school). Fond du Lac holds a special place in my heart, as it's where my story began and where I developed a deep appreciation for the beauty of Wisconsin.
Beyond my professional life, I'm an enthusiast of various interests. I have a knack for decorating and organizing, which allows me to see the potential in every home and offer you expert advice on how to make it truly yours. My love for real estate extends beyond the office, as I'm always eager to explore the latest trends and insights in the industry.
I'm not just a real estate agent; I'm your neighbor, your friend, and your trusted advisor in the journey to find your dream home or sell your property. With my education, professional experience, and connection to the Fox Valley, I'm uniquely positioned to guide you through the real estate process with care, expertise, and a commitment to your best interests.
Whether you're looking for your first home, considering an upgrade, or seeking to make a smart investment in Wisconsin's real estate market, I'm here to make the process as smooth and enjoyable as possible. I look forward to working with you and being a part of your real estate journey.
Feel free to get in touch with me for any real estate needs or inquiries. Let's take the next step together on the path to finding your perfect place to call home!
Awards
2024
Quality Service Producer
Client Reviews (27)
5.0 out of 5
(5)
Seller Review
Greg Lau, Kaukauna WI
I couldn’t be happier with Sarah’s help in selling our house. From start to finish, she went above and beyond to make the process as smooth as possible. She organized two open houses, helped us navigate and resolve some outstanding issues with the city, and maintained excellent communication throughout the entire sale. Sarah was consistently friendly, responsive, and always willing to do whatever it took to get the job done. Her dedication and professionalism made what could have been a stressful experience actually pleasant. I highly recommend Sarah to anyone looking for a real estate agent who truly cares about their clients and delivers results.
9 days ago
Seller Review
Heather Kametler, Wis
Sarah I'm so happy that we were able to work with you on selling ? our home.Century 21 and all your clients are very lucky to have you.You go above and. beyond and I'm thankful for that and if you didn't know the answer to a question you would find the answer you were on vacation but still keeping in contact with with me you are truly an amazing person and realtor Heather
13 days ago
Buyer Review
Matt Thiel, Appleton, WI
In a competitive market, Sarah helped me land the first home I made an offer on below asking price and with instant equity. That alone speaks volumes.
But what truly set her apart was her relentless commitment to finding the right home, not just closing a deal. The process felt less like a transaction and more like teaming up with a friend who genuinely had my back.
From helping me move to making sure my dog was comfortable during closing, Sarah showed up in ways most agents wouldn’t even consider.
If you’re looking for someone who’s sharp, caring, and fully invested in your success, Sarah May is your person.
1 month ago
Buyer Review
Ericka Rohde-Bloch, Appleton, WI
Sarah was amazing to work with! We would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor and would use her again if/when we are looking for another home
