44 Butler Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Local realty services provided by:CENTURY 21 Awaye Realty
44 Butler Street,Brooklyn, NY 11231
$4,250,000
- 6 Beds
- 4 Baths
- 4,176 sq. ft.
- Multi-family
- Pending
Listed by: paul m murphy, rebecca navarro, carol wang
Office: compass
MLS#:RLS20012052
Source:NY_REBNY
Price summary
- Price:$4,250,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$1,017.72
About this home
Built in the 1850’s in the Greek Revival style, 44 Butler Street is a grand 25 ft wide brick townhouse with an enviable position in Cobble Hill on a sunny low-traffic block. This gorgeous home retains many historic details, including elegant marble fireplace mantles, tin ceilings, the original staircase, wide plank subfloors, and much more. Originally built as a single-family, 44 Butler Street is currently configured as a 3-family comprising a garden/parlor floor duplex with a cellar and vault, and two floor-through apartments above. It would be easy to adapt 44 Butler Street for use as a 1-family or 2-family townhouse. Zoning allows for the addition of over 800 additional square feet.
Coming home to 44 Butler Street, you’ll ascend a wide stoop and enter into a spacious entry hall with wide plank floors, ceilings that soar close to 11-feet high and light that streams down from a large window on the staircase landing above. The garden/parlor floor duplex features a large parlor with two original black marble fireplaces and a sunny kitchen. The kitchen steps out to a large south-facing terrace perched over a deep and wide backyard. This tranquil oasis from the bustle of the city is a wonderful place to relax, entertain, and enjoy everyday life.
The parlor floor includes a half bath nicely tucked off the staircase that leads to the garden level, where you’ll find three bedrooms, a large bathroom, and a spacious laundry room. In the back glass doors open to a private brick patio.
Upstairs you’ll find two floor-through apartments which are in good condition and ready to be rented. Light streams in all day long thanks to the building’s north-south orientation. Instead of buildings across the street, there’s a playground which provides for stunning unobstructed views of Downtown Brooklyn and tremendous light. The south facing side also gets great light, given the generous depth of the block’s backyards and the low profile of the houses on Douglass Street.
44 Butler Street includes a fun historic feature rarely seen in New York City. Whereas some townhouses will include just a bit of storage space underneath the stoop, 44 Butler Street has steps that lead down to a sprawling approximately 25-foot long vault with a domed ceiling. While it’s impossible to know how various stewards of 44 Butler Street may have used this intriguing space over its 170 + year history, one could easily envision it today as a wine-cellar, workshop, rec room, speak-easy style entertainment area, and much more.
44 Butler Street is close to the renowned restaurants, boutiques, parks and other amenities that have made Cobble Hill, Boerum Hill, Carroll Gardens and Brooklyn Heights famous. Just around the corner on Court Street and Smith Street you’ll find an array of neighborhood favorites including a beloved independent bookstore called Books Are Magic, Poetica Coffee, Clover Club, Levant on Smith, Union Market, the Court Street Pastry Shop and much more. For a quick commute to Manhattan and the rest of the city, the F/G station is just a couple blocks away. The 2, 3, 4, 5, R, A, and C lines are also easily accessible, and the Pier 6 Ferry is nearby at Brooklyn Bridge Park.
Bring your contractor and architect and make this historic Cobble Hill townhouse the backdrop for your next chapter in Brooklyn....
Contact an agent
Home facts
- Year built:1856
- Subdivision & Development:Cobble Hill
- Listing ID #:RLS20012052
- Added:493 day(s) ago
- Updated:August 02, 2026 at 08:35 AM
Rooms and interior
- Bedrooms:6
- Total bathrooms:4
- Full bathrooms:3
- Half bathrooms:1
- Rooms Total:18
- Living area:4,176 sq. ft.
Structure and exterior
- Year built:1856
- Building area:4,176 sq. ft.
Finances and disclosures
- Price:$4,250,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$1,017.72
- Tax amount:$9,960
This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed and may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. © 2026 The Real Estate Board of New York, Inc., All rights reserved. RLS Data display by Coldwell Banker Warburg This advertisement does not suggest that the broker has a listing in this property or properties or that any property is currently available. NY_REBNY Member Broker: Arlene WayeNew listings near 44 Butler Street
- New
$1,998,000Active-- beds -- baths3,825 sq. ft.1140 Willoughby Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11237
MLS# 1033086Listed by: PRIME AMERICA REAL ESTATE INC - New
$1,680,000Active5 beds 3 baths2,000 sq. ft.1433 Bay Ridge Parkway, Brooklyn, NY 11209
MLS# 503459Listed by: E HOUSE REALTY & MGT. INC. - New
$1,895,000Active2 beds 2 baths925 sq. ft.145 Conselyea Street #GARDEN, Brooklyn, NY 11211
MLS# RLS20105757Listed by: COMPASS - New
$1,150,000Active2 beds 3 baths1,199 sq. ft.157 Rogers Avenue #GARDEN, Brooklyn, NY 11216
MLS# RLS20106873Listed by: COMPASS - New
$1,350,000Active9 beds 3 baths3,600 sq. ft.236 Schaefer Street, Brooklyn, NY 11207
MLS# 1033450Listed by: GLOBAL XCHANGE REALTY, LLC - New
$1,985,000Active2 beds 2 baths1,192 sq. ft.145 Conselyea Street #2, Brooklyn, NY 11211
MLS# RLS20104447Listed by: COMPASS - New
$3,835,000Active3 beds 4 baths2,225 sq. ft.145 Conselyea Street #PH, Brooklyn, NY 11211
MLS# RLS20106121Listed by: COMPASS - Open Sun, 12:30 to 1:30pmNew
$599,000Active1 beds 1 baths570 Westminster Road #E6, Brooklyn, NY 11230
MLS# RLS20106853Listed by: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE - New
$980,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,064 sq. ft.2073 West 8th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11223
MLS# 503447Listed by: TIGER REALTY - New
$850,000Active2 beds 2 baths889 sq. ft.2286 Cropsey Avenue #10B, Brooklyn, NY 11214
MLS# RLS20106835Listed by: SERHANT
Protect your home and budget from life's surprises with an Assurant Home Warranty, backed by a partner that supports you through every step of homeownership. Explore Plans.
©2026 Century 21 Real Estate LLC. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, the CENTURY 21 Logo and C21® are service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Century 21 Real Estate LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate.