5759 New York 23a, Tannersville, NY 12485
Local realty services provided by:CENTURY 21 New West Properties
5759 New York 23a,Tannersville, NY 12485
$850,000
- 9 Beds
- 11 Baths
- 6,000 sq. ft.
- Single family
- Active
Listed by: jason dugo
Office: dugo realty
MLS#:20261688
Source:NY_MLSUC
Price summary
- Price:$850,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$141.67
About this home
Positioned at the east entrance to Tannersville, this 11 unit mixed-use building sits on a prominent corner lot directly across from Town Hall, serving as a gateway property into one of the Catskills' most active four-season markets. Held by the same ownership for over 35 years, opportunities of this scale and consistency rarely come available in this immediate area.
The building consists of 9 residential apartments and 2 commercial office suites, offering a diverse and functional unit mix of 3 one-bedroom apartments, 3 studio apartments with lofted sleeping areas, and 3 traditional studio units. All units are currently rented on a month-to-month basis, providing immediate income with the ability to adjust rents over time. The property generates approximately 117k in annual gross income, with operating expenses around 49k, resulting in a net operating income near 68k. At the current asking price, this equates to an approximate 7.8 cap rate, positioning the asset competitively for investors seeking both yield and upside.
Set across four levels, including a lower-level basement with additional apartments, the building offers an efficient layout with multiple access points. The property is serviced by municipal water and sewer, has a new roof and benefits from ample off-street parking, a key feature for both residential and commercial tenants.
Located just minutes to Hunter Mountain and within walking distance to Main Street, shops, dining, and local amenities, the property is ideally positioned to capture steady, year-round rental demand. Its proximity to North and South Lake, Kaaterskill Falls, and surrounding hiking trails further enhances its appeal.
This is a proven, income-producing asset with a strong rental history, consistent occupancy, and clear upside potential through rent optimization and leasing of the commercial suites. A rare offering in a tightly held market, well suited for investors looking to establish or expand in the Catskills....
Contact an agent
Home facts
- Year built:1960
- Listing ID #:20261688
- Added:147 day(s) ago
- Updated:September 12, 2026 at 03:45 PM
Rooms and interior
- Bedrooms:9
- Total bathrooms:11
- Full bathrooms:9
- Half bathrooms:2
- Basement:Yes
- Basement Description:FInished, Walk-Out Access
- Living area:6,000 sq. ft.
Structure and exterior
- Year built:1960
- Building area:6,000 sq. ft.
- Lot area:0.93 Acres
- Exterior Features:Deck
Utilities
- Sewer:Public Sewer
Finances and disclosures
- Price:$850,000
- Price per sq. ft.:$141.67
- Tax amount:$5,935
Parking
- Parking description:Off street, Parking Lot
New listings near 5759 New York 23a
$675,000Active4 beds 3 baths2,873 sq. ft.81 Baker Court Drive, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20264979Listed by: COLDWELL BANKER VILLAGE GREEN
$299,000Active1 beds 1 baths480 sq. ft.136 Penrose Park, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20264971Listed by: DUGO REALTY
$100,000Active0.5 AcresPark Lane, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 1030477Listed by: EREALTY ADVISORS, INC
$1,300,000Active4 beds 3 baths2,820 sq. ft.159 Park Lane, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 1028040Listed by: EREALTY ADVISORS, INC
$749,999Active3 beds 2 baths1,504 sq. ft.425 North Lake Road, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20263803Listed by: DUGO REALTY
$615,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,878 sq. ft.151 County Road 23c, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20263685Listed by: DUGO REALTY
$295,000Active3 beds 1 baths856 sq. ft.35 S Main, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20263423Listed by: WIN MORRISON REALTY - W
$929,000Active4 beds 4 baths2,266 sq. ft.5914 Main Street, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20263344Listed by: GREENE ACRES REAL ESTATE & MAN
$375,000Active4 beds 2 baths1,920 sq. ft.51 Grays Lane, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20263168Listed by: DUGO REALTY
$455,000Active3 beds 2 baths1,296 sq. ft.6570 Route 23a, Tannersville, NY 12485
MLS# 20263078Listed by: HUNTER MOUNTAIN REALTY